How to use this page
Each lens is a set of questions to ask about your game design — not a rule, recipe, or checklist. No single lens is sufficient on its own. The value comes from applying multiple lenses in combination, especially when a design problem resists diagnosis.
Lenses are grouped here by chapter/topic area, matching the book’s structure. Page numbers refer to the first edition (Schell, 2008).
For fuller explanation of the methodology, see design-lenses .
Card deck available at artofgamedesign.com.
Experience & what games are (Ch. 2–3)
# Lens What it asks p. 1 Essential Experience What experience do I want to create? Is everything in the game working toward that experience? 21 2 Surprise Does my game have enough variety and surprise? What will players be surprised by? 26 3 Fun Is my game fun? When it stops being fun, why? 27 4 Curiosity What questions does my game put in the player’s mind? Are they compelling enough to drive play? 30 5 Endogenous Value How do players feel about the game’s items and currency? How can I make them feel more valuable? 32 6 Problem Solving What problems must the player solve? Does the game keep generating new problems? 37
Game elements (Ch. 4–5)
# Lens What it asks p. 7 Elemental Tetrad Am I using all four elements (Mechanics, Story, Aesthetics, Technology)? Are they in harmony? 43 8 Holographic Design Can I see skin and skeleton simultaneously? What elements make the experience enjoyable or detract from it? 46 9 Unification Does everything in my game serve the same theme? How can disparate elements be unified? 53 10 Resonance Does my game have something ineffable that resonates deeply? 56 11 Infinite Inspiration What is my game really about? What other non-game experiences can inspire it? 59 12 Problem Statement Have I stated my design problem clearly? What are my constraints? Am I solving the right problem? 62
Ideation & prototyping (Ch. 6–7)
# Lens What it asks p. 13 Eight Filters Does my game pass through all eight critical filters? (fun, will work, innovative, doable, etc.) 78 14 Risk Mitigation What could go wrong? Have I identified and addressed the biggest risks early? 86 15 The Toy Is my game fun to play with even before goals are added? Is there an intrinsic toylike quality? 90
The player (Ch. 8–9)
# Lens What it asks p. 16 The Player What are my players’ needs and desires? Am I designing for them or for myself? 106 17 Pleasure What pleasures does my game provide? Which am I neglecting? 112 18 Flow Is the game in the right zone of challenge relative to player skill? Does it keep players in flow? 122 19 Needs Which of the player’s fundamental needs does my game fulfil? Could it fulfil them better? 127 20 Judgment Does my game judge players fairly? Do players feel judged in a way that motivates rather than discourages? 128
Game mechanics: space, objects, actions (Ch. 10)
# Lens What it asks p. 21 Functional Space What is the functional shape of my game space? Does it match what the gameplay needs? 135 22 Dynamic State What information changes during the game? Does the changing state create interesting decisions? 140 23 Emergence How many ways can players achieve goals? Do simple rules produce complex, interesting outcomes? 143 24 Action What are the verbs of my game? Are the actions meaningful and sufficient? 144 25 Goals Are the goals of the game clear? Achievable? Rewarding? Are there multiple layers of goals? 149 26 Rules Are the rules complete and consistent? Do they support the intended experience? 150 27 Skill What skills does my game require? Do the required skills match the skills my audience has and wants to develop? 153
Chance & probability (Ch. 10 cont.)
# Lens What it asks p. 28 Expected Value What is the expected value of each choice? Do players understand the risk/reward of their options? 167 29 Chance What random events does my game include? Is the player comfortable with the level of randomness? 169
Balance (Ch. 11)
# Lens What it asks p. 30 Fairness Is my game fair to all players? Are different strategies equally viable? 176 31 Challenge Is the game appropriately challenging throughout? Does it scale well? 179 32 Meaningful Choices Are the choices players make truly meaningful? Is there a dominant strategy making other choices irrelevant? 181 33 Triangularity Are there high-risk/high-reward options that players choose voluntarily? 182 34 Skill vs. Chance Does the balance of skill and chance feel right for my audience? 184 35 Head and Hands Does my game require the right balance of thinking and physical skill? 185 36 Competition Is the game competitive in a satisfying way? Can players of different skill levels enjoy it? 186 37 Cooperation Does cooperative play feel meaningful? Are players genuinely dependent on each other? 187 38 Competition vs. Cooperation Is the balance of competition and cooperation right? 187 39 Time Is the game the right length? Does time pressure enhance or damage the experience? 189 40 Reward What rewards does the game give? Are they the right type, at the right frequency? 191 41 Punishment What are the punishments? Are they severe enough to create tension but not so severe as to frustrate? 194 42 Simplicity/Complexity Is the game as simple as it can be while still being deep? 196 43 Elegance Is each game element doing multiple jobs? Can anything be simplified without losing depth? 198 44 Character Do my characters have good game balance? Do they feel meaningfully different? 199 45 Imagination Does the game fill in gaps with imagination? Is it suggestive rather than exhaustive? 201 46 Economy Does the game have a well-balanced internal economy? Are resources flowing as intended? 204 47 Balance Is the game as a whole balanced? Are all the other balance lenses satisfied? 205
Puzzles (Ch. 12)
# Lens What it asks p. 48 Accessibility Is the game easy to learn? Can players understand what to do immediately? 213 49 Visible Progress Can players see that they are making progress toward their goal? 214 50 Parallelism Are there parallel challenges at different difficulty levels so players can always make progress? 216 51 The Pyramid Does the game have a pyramid structure where small challenges build to larger ones? 217 52 The Puzzle Does each puzzle have a clear goal? Is the solution satisfying to find? 219
Interface (Ch. 13)
# Lens What it asks p. 53 Control Does the player feel in control? Can they do what they intend to do? 222 54 Physical Interface Is the physical interface intuitive? Does it suit the game’s feel? 226 55 Virtual Interface Is the virtual UI clear and unobtrusive? Does it give the player what they need without overwhelming them? 226 56 Transparency Does the interface teach players how to play? Is the game’s logic visible through it? 227 57 Feedback Does the game clearly and quickly communicate what is happening? 230 58 Juiciness Is every action rewarded with satisfying feedback? Does the game feel alive and responsive? 233 59 Channels and Dimensions Am I using all available information channels (audio, visual, haptic)? Am I overloading any single channel? 238 60 Modes Are my game modes necessary? Do players know which mode they are in at all times? 240
Interest & engagement (Ch. 14)
# Lens What it asks p. 61 Interest Curve What does the interest curve of my game look like? Does it have a strong hook, build well, and end at a climax? 252 62 Inherent Interest How interesting is my game at its very start, before the player has invested anything? 254 63 Beauty Does my game have beauty — in visuals, sound, mechanics, or structure? 255 64 Projection Does the player project into the game world? What makes the player feel part of the experience? 257
Story (Ch. 15–16)
# Lens What it asks p. 65 The Story Machine Does my game generate interesting stories naturally through play? 266 66 The Obstacle Are the obstacles in my game meaningful? Do they make the story more compelling? 271 67 Simplicity and Transcendence Does my game provide an escape into a simpler world with greater power? 272 68 The Hero’s Journey Does my game follow the hero’s journey structure? Where does it diverge, and why? 275 69 The Weirdest Thing What is the strangest element in my game? Does it undermine believability or uniquely define it? 279 70 Story Does my game tell a good story? Are the story elements integrated with the mechanics? 280 71 Freedom Does the player feel free? Does the structure of the game feel like liberation or constraint? 284 72 Indirect Control Am I using indirect control (constraints, goals, interface, visuals, characters, music) to guide players naturally? 293 73 Collusion Am I working with the player as a partner to create a great experience? 298
Worlds (Ch. 17)
# Lens What it asks p. 74 The World Is my world so rich that it feels it could exist independently of the game? 307
Characters (Ch. 18)
# Lens What it asks p. 75 The Avatar Does the player avatar have the right qualities for the game? Does the player feel attached to them? 314 76 Character Function Does each character serve a clear function in the game’s experience? 316 77 Character Traits Do my characters have defining traits? Are those traits expressed consistently through action? 317 78 The Interpersonal Circumplex Do character relationships have the right mix of dominance and affiliation? 319 79 The Character Web Do the relationships between characters create interesting tensions and dynamics? 321 80 Status Do the relative status relationships between characters feel right? Do players feel appropriate status? 323 81 Character Transformation Does the player character change and grow? Is the transformation earned? 327
Spaces & aesthetics (Ch. 19–20)
# Lens What it asks p. 82 Inner Contradiction Does my game world have an “inner contradiction” — a quality that gives it life and tension? 335 83 The Nameless Quality Does my game have a quality that is hard to name but immediately felt — a sense of aliveness? 337
# Lens What it asks p. 84 Friendship Does my game support and strengthen friendships? 361 85 Expression Does my game give players meaningful ways to express themselves? 363 86 Community Does my game support a healthy community? What are the social structures it enables? 367 87 Griefing How does my game protect players from griefing? Is punishment for grief behaviour proportional? 370
Team & production (Ch. 23–25)
# Lens What it asks p. 88 Love Do I love my game? Does my team? If not — why not, and does it matter? 375 89 The Team Is my team communicating well? Do they share a vision? 380 90 Documentation Do my documents serve clear purposes? Are they helping the team communicate or just generating noise? 387 91 Playtesting Am I playtesting early and often? Am I asking the right questions and getting the right players? 401
Technology (Ch. 26)
# Lens What it asks p. 92 Technology What technologies does my game require? Are they foundational or decorational? 412 93 The Crystal Ball What will technology look like when my game ships? Am I betting on the right future? 413
Client & business (Ch. 27–29)
# Lens What it asks p. 94 The Client What does the client truly want? What are their stated vs. unstated desires? 420 95 The Pitch Does my pitch communicate the essence of the game? Does it excite the listener? 432 96 Profit Does my game have a viable business model? Do I understand the financials? 439
# Lens What it asks p. 97 Transformation How will playing my game change the player? Is that change positive? 452 98 Responsibility Am I designing responsibly? What are the ethical implications of my design choices? 457 99 The Raven What is the raven on my shoulder — the voice that questions every decision? Am I listening to it? 460 100 Your Secret Purpose Why am I making this game? What is my true purpose, and does my game reflect it? 461